Everything Sucks!: Complete Story and Character Guide
Boring High, 1996 — an A/V club, a drama club, one movie, and the completion rate that ended it all.
Everything Sucks! premiered on Netflix on February 16, 2018 (1 season, 10 half-hour episodes), created by showrunners Ben York Jones and Michael Mohan. Set at Boring High in Boring, Oregon in 1996, it follows A/V-club freshman Luke O'Neil (Jahi Di'Allo Winston) crushing on sophomore Kate Messner (Peyton Kennedy) as the clubs unite to make a movie. According to Variety, Netflix cancelled it on April 6, 2018 — under two months after debut. At 7.4 IMDb and 73% Tomatoes it was liked; Kate's coming-out arc was widely praised.
The cancellation became a case study: Netflix's Cindy Holland admitted passion for the show at TCA but cited below-average completion — many viewers never finished the 23-minute first episode, per Business Insider and Vulture. At roughly $1.5M per episode (under $15M total, per Vulture via Business Insider), even cheap could not survive unwatched. House of Cards' Beau Willimon publicly mourned it.
Full Season Recap
Season 1 — Boring, 1996 (2018)
Luke pursues Kate; Kate discovers she likes Emaline Addario (Sydney Sweeney) instead — the season's true spine, played with celebrated care by Kennedy. McQuaid (Rio Mangini) and Tyler (Quinn Liebling) round out the A/V crew; Oliver (Elijah Stevenson) complicates Emaline's orbit. Parents Ken Messner (Patch Darragh) and Sherry O'Neil (Claudine Nako) carry the adult counterplot, including Luke's absent father Leroy. The California shoot trip (episode 8) peaks the movie dream; the finale lands Kate's truth and Luke's heartbreak without cruelty. Sydney Sweeney, pre-Euphoria, steals every scene she enters.
Character Guide
Kate Messner — The Heart
Peyton Kennedy plays the principal's daughter discovering her sexuality in 1996 — the performance critics from The Guardian to Vulture singled out.
Luke O'Neil — The Crush
Jahi Di'Allo Winston grounds the show's sweetness: abandoned by his father, brave about his feelings, learning rejection is survivable.
Emaline, McQuaid & Tyler — The Orbit
Sweeney's Emaline, Mangini's McQuaid and Liebling's Tyler give the ensemble its friction and warmth; the supporting thinness critics noted, but beloved anyway.
Ken & Sherry — The Adults
Darragh and Nako play parents as people, not obstacles — the show's quietest innovation.
Ending Explained
The finale resolves the season's emotional arcs — Kate's coming out faced, Luke's crush survived, the movie made — while leaving the ensemble's futures open. It plays as a complete first chapter rather than a cliffhanger, which is precisely why cancellation stung differently here: not a mystery denied, but a growth viewers were barred from watching. Netflix confirmed it would not return.
Enjoyed this article? This site imagines satisfying endings for cancelled shows — support my work so I can keep writing.
☕ Support UsWhy Was Everything Sucks! Cancelled?
Netflix cancelled Everything Sucks! on April 6, 2018 after one season of 10 episodes, per Variety. Holland's TCA explanation — completion below average, no room to grow the audience — plus the Vulture-reported episode-one exodus made it the textbook completion-rate kill, per Business Insider. Cheap at $1.5M an episode, but unwatched is unwatched.
Frequently Asked Questions
Was Everything Sucks! cancelled?
Why was Everything Sucks! cancelled?
Does Everything Sucks! end on a cliffhanger?
Explore our library of fan-written conclusions and our YA adaptations guide.